Buffalo sentencing updates: Victim’s family member lunges at mass shooter

Buffalo sentencing updates: Victim’s family member lunges at mass shooter
Buffalo sentencing updates: Victim’s family member lunges at mass shooter
John Normile/Getty Images

(BUFFALO, N.Y.) — Anger boiled over Wednesday at the sentencing hearing of Buffalo mass shooter Payton Gendron, when a family member of a victim charged after Gendron and had to be restrained by courtroom guards.

The explosive moment came as Barbara Massey whose sister, Katherine Massey, was giving an emotional victim impact statement: “I want to personally choke you,” she said to 19-year-old Gendron.

As she was speaking, a relative lunged toward Gendron, who was seated at the defense table sobbing in tears. Guards quickly restrained the man as they hustled Gendron from the courtroom. Judge Susan Eagan temporarily halted the hearing and called for order in the court.

“I am sure you all are disturbed by the physicality we’ve seen today. I understand the emotion and I understand the anger but we cannot have that in the courtroom,” Eagan said.

Garnell Whitfield Jr., whose 86-year-old mother died in the Tops supermarket massacre last May, said he’s not interested in hearing what the gunman has to say when he plans to apologize to victims’ families.

“Nothing he’s going to say to me is going to bring my mother back. It’s not going to take away the pain of losing her,” Whitfield, the retired Buffalo fire commissioner, told ABC News. “I’m assuming that whatever he’s doing, he’s doing it for himself.”

Gendron, who killed 10 people on May 14, will be sentenced later today to life in prison without the possibility of parole. He pleaded guilty in November to 15 charges, including murder and attempted murder. He is the first person in state history to be charged with domestic terrorism motivated by hate. He has pleaded guilty.

In addition to the state case, he is facing hate and domestic terrorism charges in federal court. His attorneys said he might consider pleading guilty if prosecutors agree not to pursue the death penalty.

Gendron, a self-professed white supremacist who livestreamed part of the attack, plans to make a statement at Wednesday’s hearing, in which he is expected to apologize to the loved ones of those he gunned down, sources told The Buffalo News.

Wayne Jones, whose 65-year-old mother was killed in the rampage, said he plans to speak at the sentencing hearing.

“My message for him will be [about] mistakes, that there are mistakes you can’t take back and now you have to live with the consequences,” Jones told ABC News. “He can apologize. I’ll respect that, but he needs to sit and think about the situation as much as I do everyday. For me, it never goes away.”

Jones and Whitfield are among the family members of those killed who have submitted victim impact statements to the court.

“The emotions of the families that we speak for run the entire gamut. There are those who are anxious to see the maximum penalty imposed on the shooter but there are also family members who regard the shooter as irrelevant and pay him no deference as they strive to achieve something positive from this horrific experience,” Terry Connors, an attorney who represents several families who lost loved ones.

Attorney John Elmore, who also represents the families of three victims, said more than a dozen people are expected to deliver victim impact statements before Judge Susan Eagan imposes the sentence.

Whitfield told ABC News on Tuesday he’s yet to decide whether to read the statement in court, saying, “If I do, it will be on behalf of my father.”

Whitfield’s father, 88-year-old Garnell W. Whitfield Sr., suffers from dementia and lives in a nursing home.

Gendron planned the massacre for months — including previously traveling twice to the Tops store he targeted, a more than three-hour drive from his home in Conklin, New York — to scout the layout and count the number of Black people present, according to prosecutors. Wearing tactical gear, body armor, and wielding an AR-15 style rifle he legally purchased and illegally modified, Gendron committed the rampage on a Saturday afternoon when prosecutors said he knew the store would be full of Black shoppers.

The attack was caught on a Tops supermarket surveillance camera and a helmet camera worn by Gendron that he used to livestream on Twitch. Prior to the attack, he also posted a racist screed online containing the names of past mass shooters he admired.

“Whatever he does in court is a procedural thing. His fate is sealed, there’s no discretion in the sentencing. It’s life without parole, period,” Whitfield said.

Whitfield said any statement he makes will be focused on “the people and places and things that empowered him, that radicalized him, that helped him do what he did.”

In October, New York State Attorney General Letitia James released the report, alleging several online platforms played roles in the May 14 mass shooting by radicalizing Gendron, as he consumed voluminous amounts of racist and violent content, and then by allowing him to broadcast the deadly attack. The report found anonymous, largely unmoderated websites and platforms, like 4chan, allegedly influenced Gendron. It also said livestreaming platforms like Twitch were “weaponized” to publicize and encourage copycat attacks.

Ordinarily, social media platforms cannot be sued over content, but Elmore told ABC News there are grounds for viable suits against several social media platforms over the way they’re designed to promote constant engagement. “The litigation we are preparing will deter the social media platforms from continuing their policies of directing their algorithms to radicalize people to become dangerous to our society,” Elmore said.

Elmore added that Gendron “was trained and inspired to commit this tremendous murder by social media.”

“All those things are still in place and still in a position to continue the perpetuation of all the injustices and evils that are part of our society,” Whitfield said. “[Gendron] did this for attention. Let’s not give it to him.”

Copyright © 2023, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.

Buffalo sentencing updates: Judge says ‘no mercy’ as shooter sentenced to life after chaotic hearing

Buffalo sentencing updates: Victim’s family member lunges at mass shooter
Buffalo sentencing updates: Victim’s family member lunges at mass shooter
John Normile/Getty Images

(BUFFALO, N.Y.) — Anger boiled over Wednesday as Buffalo mass shooter Payton Gendron was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility parole, with a judge telling the 19-year-old he deserved “no mercy” and a victim’s family member lunging at him in the courtroom.

After hearing emotional statements from the families of the victims, Eagan imposed the mandatory sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole, saying, “Our characters are being tested, the future of our nation is at stake.”

“There is no place for you or your ignorant, hateful and evil ideologies in a civilized society. There can be no mercy for you, no understanding, no second chances. The damage you have caused is too great and the people you have hurt are too valuable to this community,” Eagan told Gendron. “You will never see the light of day as a free man ever again.”

She imposed a sentence of life in prison without parole for all 10 victims he killed on May 14, 2022, at a Tops market on the east side of Buffalo and 25 years for each of the three victims he shot and wounded.

Earlier in the hearing, an explosive moment occurred Barbara Massey whose sister, Katherine Massey, was giving an emotional victim impact statement: “I want to personally choke you and leave my fingers on your neck,” she said to Gendron.

As she was speaking, a relative standing next to her lunged toward Gendron, who was seated at the defense table. Guards quickly restrained the man as they hustled Gendron from the courtroom. Eagan temporarily halted the hearing and called for order in the court.

“I am sure you all are disturbed by the physicality we’ve seen today. I understand the emotion and I understand the anger but we cannot have that in the courtroom,” Eagan said.

The first victim impact statement was read by Kimberly Salter, the widow of Aaron Salter Jr., the retired Buffalo police officer and armed guard at the Tops store who was killed when he confronted Gendron, firing shots that bounced off the killer body armor.

Kimberly Salter told the court why she came wearing red and black: “Red for the blood [her husband] shed for his family and for his community and black because we are still grieving.”

She read passages from the Bible, emphasizing the scripture, “You will reap what you so.”

Simone Crawley, the granddaughter of 86-year-year-old Ruth Whitfield, the oldest victim killed in rampage, told Gendron, “You clearly did not value your own life, which allowed you to devalue the lives of others.”

“Even with all the heartache you caused, you have failed to break our family’s spirit. You thought you broke us, but you awoke us,” Crawley went on. “We all know the pure hatred and motivations behind your heinous crime and we are here to tell you that you failed.”

Wayne Jones, the only child of murder victim Celestine Chaney, told Gendron, “You took from us a loving mother, grandmother, sister, aunt cousin and friend.”

“Because of your senseless act, we will never have another birthday, or get together, another celebration,” Jones said. “While I was writing this, tears fell from my eyes, thinking about what a beautiful person you took.”

Jones, wearing a cross with containing a photo of his mother, told Gendron that because of “your hate, which you learned from the internet, I want you to remember some of the things that I say to you.”

“Mistakes, some are big and some are small. This one here is a real big one that you can’t take back. You have to live with this one, bro, just as I have to live with this every day,” Jones said. “I’m a parent and I feel sorry for your parents. You will never get to hug them again, like I won’t. You will never get to see your grandparents again.”

Referring to a federal case still pending against Gendron on charges that could get him the death penalty, Jones said, “I don’t wish the death penalty on you. I hope they keep you alive so you have to suffer with the thought of what you did for the rest of your life. To me killing you is the easy way out.”

After other family members spoke, Gendron offered a brief apology, saying he was “very sorry for all the pain” he caused “for stealing the lives of your loved ones.”

“I did a terrible thing that day. I shot people because they were Black,” Gendron said.

Garnell Whitfield Jr., the son of Ruth Whitfield, summited a victim impact statement but did not speak in court..

“Nothing [the shooter] is going to say to me is going to bring my mother back. It’s not going to take away the pain of losing her,” Whitfield, the retired Buffalo fire commissioner, told ABC News. “I’m assuming that whatever he’s doing, he’s doing it for himself.”

Gendron pleaded guilty in November to 15 charges, including murder and attempted murder. He is the first person in state history to be charged with domestic terrorism motivated by hate.

In addition to the state case, he is facing hate and domestic terrorism charges in federal court. His attorneys said he might consider pleading guilty if prosecutors agree not to pursue the death penalty.

Gendron planned the massacre for months — including previously traveling twice to the Tops store he targeted, a more than three-hour drive from his home in Conklin, New York — to scout the layout and count the number of Black people present, according to prosecutors. Wearing tactical gear, body armor, and wielding an AR-15 style rifle he legally purchased and illegally modified, Gendron committed the rampage on a Saturday afternoon when prosecutors said he knew the store would be full of Black shoppers.

The attack was caught on a Tops supermarket surveillance camera and a helmet camera worn by Gendron that he used to livestream on Twitch. Prior to the attack, he also posted a racist screed online containing the names of past mass shooters he admired.

Whitfield said his written statement focused on “the people and places and things that empowered him, that radicalized him, that helped him do what he did.”

In October, New York State Attorney General Letitia James released the report, alleging several online platforms played roles in the May 14 mass shooting by radicalizing Gendron, as he consumed voluminous amounts of racist and violent content, and then by allowing him to broadcast the deadly attack. The report found anonymous, largely unmoderated websites and platforms, like 4chan, allegedly influenced Gendron. It also said livestreaming platforms like Twitch were “weaponized” to publicize and encourage copycat attacks.

Ordinarily, social media platforms cannot be sued over content, but Elmore told ABC News there are grounds for viable suits against several social media platforms over the way they’re designed to promote constant engagement. “The litigation we are preparing will deter the social media platforms from continuing their policies of directing their algorithms to radicalize people to become dangerous to our society,” Elmore said.

Elmore added that Gendron “was trained and inspired to commit this tremendous murder by social media.”

“All those things are still in place and still in a position to continue the perpetuation of all the injustices and evils that are part of our society,” Whitfield said. “[Gendron] did this for attention. Let’s not give it to him.”

Copyright © 2023, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.

Charges dismissed against reporter arrested at Ohio train derailment

Charges dismissed against reporter arrested at Ohio train derailment
Charges dismissed against reporter arrested at Ohio train derailment
Ilkay Dede / EyeEm/Getty Images

(EAST PALESTINE, Ohio) — Trespassing and resisting arrest charges were dismissed Wednesday against NewsNation reporter Evan Lambert, who was arrested at a press conference last week about the East Palestine, Ohio, train derailment.

“My office has reviewed the relevant video and documentary evidence, and is dismissing the charges against Evan Lambert as unsupported by sufficient evidence,” Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost announced Wednesday.

“While journalists could conceivably be subject to criminal charges for trespassing in some situations, this incident is not one of them. The reporter was lawfully present at a press conference called by the Governor of the state. His conduct was consistent with the purpose of the event and his role as a reporter,” Yost added.

Lambert had been charged with resisting arrest, a second-degree misdemeanor, and criminal trespassing, a fourth-degree misdemeanor.

According to NewsNation, Lambert was doing a live report while Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine spoke at a press conference about the cleanup efforts following a train derailment in a small Ohio village, prompting law enforcement to ask Lambert to be quiet. NewsNation said that Lambert concluded the segment before being asked to leave.

Multiple videos from the incident show officers arresting and subsequently forcibly removing Lambert.

“I’m still processing what was a traumatic event for me, in the context of a time where we are hyper aware of how frequently some police interactions with people of color can end in much worse circumstances. That is not lost on me,” Lambert said in a statement.

He continued, “At the same time, as a journalist who has spent more than a decade covering crime, courts and more recently federal law enforcement, I have great respect for the officers who do their jobs each day with integrity, civil rights, justice and safety at the core of their mission.”

DeWine’s office said he did not see the incident but heard a “disagreement,” according to his press secretary.

“Regardless of the intent, arresting a journalist reporting at a press conference is a serious matter,” Yost said. “Ohio protects a free press under its constitution, and state officials should remember to exercise a heightened level of restraint in using arrest powers.”

ABC News’ Peter Charalambous and Will McDuffie contributed to this report.

Copyright © 2023, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.

Michigan State mass shooting victims: What to know about three lives lost

Michigan State mass shooting victims: What to know about three lives lost
Michigan State mass shooting victims: What to know about three lives lost
mphotoi/Getty Images

(EAST LANSING, Mich.) — Three students were killed and five others were wounded in Monday night’s mass shooting at Michigan State University.

The Michigan State University Police Department has released the names of the young lives lost.

Arielle Anderson

Arielle Anderson was a junior from Grosse Pointe, Michigan.

Her family remembered her as a “precious daughter, granddaughter, sister, niece, cousin, and friend” in a statement shared Tuesday evening through her mother’s employer, Comerica Bank.

“As much as we loved her, she loved us and others even more,” the family said. “She was passionate about helping her friends and family, assisting children and serving people.”

Anderson, who was described as “sweet and loving with an infectious smile,” wanted to be a surgeon, her family said.

“Driven by her aspiration to tend to the health and welfare of others as a surgeon, she was working diligently to graduate from Michigan State University early to achieve her goals as quickly as possible,” the family said.

“We are absolutely devastated by this heinous act of violence upon her and many other innocent victims,” the statement added.

Brian Fraser

Brian Fraser was a sophomore, also from Grosse Pointe.

Fraser’s “light shined bright with love, leadership and kindness,” according to a statement from his church.

Fraser was president of the Phi Delta Theta fraternity at Michigan State.

“As the leader of his chapter, Brian was a great friend to his Phi Delt brothers, the Greek community at Michigan State, and those he interacted with on campus,” Phi Delta Theta said in a statement.

Fraser was on his high school’s swimming and diving team.

“Brian had an infectious smile and sense of humor that could light up the pool deck and bring laughter to the entire team,” the team said in a statement.

Alexandria Verner

Alexandria Verner was a junior from Clawson, Michigan.

Verner was a “tremendous” student and athlete while at Clawson High School, Clawson Public Schools said in a statement.

She “exemplified kindness every day of her life,” the school district said. “If you knew her, you loved her and we will forever remember the lasting impact she has had on all of us.”

Billy Shellenbarger, a family friend and Verner’s high school principal, described her as empathetic, humble and a leader who carried herself with integrity.

“Very, very kind to everyone she came in contact with. Always positive. Incredibly compassionate. Just embodied so many of those things you would want in your daughter, your student, your sister,” Shellenbarger, now the Clawson Public Schools superintendent, told ABC News.

Verner was a forensics major at Michigan State. She was in her lab class at Berkey Hall when she was shot, Shellenbarger said.

Verner is survived by her parents, older brother and younger sister.

Shellenbarger asked others to “be kind, like Al was.”

“Help somebody like Al did. And walk a path of impact like she was doing,” he continued. “And if you can do that in her honor, then we’re taking some steps in the right direction, because that was exactly the path that she was walking.”

Copyright © 2023, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.

What is ESG investing and why are some Republicans criticizing it?

What is ESG investing and why are some Republicans criticizing it?
What is ESG investing and why are some Republicans criticizing it?
Matteo Colombo/Getty Images

(NEW YORK) — The culture wars, fought nationwide in school board meetings and college classrooms, have entered a new arena: Wall Street.

A sharp political divide has emerged over environmental, social and governance investing, or ESG, a type of investing that takes into account non-financial information about a company, such as its climate impact and staff diversity.

Prominent Republican politicians, such as Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, have assailed ESG as “woke” capitalism that prioritizes liberal goals over investor returns, harming U.S. companies deemed insufficiently progressive and, in turn, hindering the wider economy.

Supporters of ESG, including financial firms that manage trillions in assets, have said considerations beyond the bottom line deliver the best financial gains. In weighing the economic threat posed by climate change, for instance, investors ensure the long-term health of their portfolio.

“There’s some risk that we could have red and blue banks, red and blue supermarkets,” Witold Henisz, faculty director of the ESG Initiative at The Wharton School of Business at the University of Pennsylvania, told ABC News. “America is more and more polarized.”

Here’s what to know about ESG and the political backlash against it:

What is ESG investing?

For decades, prevailing corporate wisdom held that companies face a choice between actions that are socially beneficial and ones that maximize shareholder value, said Alison Taylor, a professor of business at New York University who focuses on corporate responsibility and ethics.

ESG, by contrast, is an approach to investing that examines a company’s social or environmental impact precisely because it considers non-financial information useful for determining whether the company would deliver strong investor returns.

“The business would do good for the world and make more money,” Taylor told ABC News.

Depending on a given investor or policy, ESG takes into account a range of business practices, such as the release of carbon emissions or pollution, the treatment of employees and the presence of minorities within a company’s leadership.

Sustainable investment based on ESG criteria has grown to a $35.5 trillion industry, according to a study from the Global Sustainable Investment Alliance in 2020.

How has ESG risen to prominence on Wall Street?

Over roughly the past 15 years, ESG has shifted from an upstart financial trend to a mainstream strategy touted by industry titans, experts said.

The rise of ESG has been propelled by growing awareness about the negative effects of some corporate practices, in part due to the rise of social media, said Taylor of New York University. She also credited a young generation of investors, which has brought a focus especially on the role that companies play in exacerbating climate change.

Financial leaders have also taken up the cause. One major promoter of ESG, Larry Fink, the CEO of BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager, has highlighted for years the importance of non-financial information in assessing investment opportunities.

“Stakeholder capitalism is not about politics,” Fink said last year in a letter to CEOs. “It is not a social or ideological agenda. It is not ‘woke.’ It is capitalism, driven by mutually beneficial relationships between you and the employees, customers, suppliers, and communities your company relies on to prosper.”

The surge of ESG adoption has also coincided with a slew of studies that demonstrate its effectiveness in yielding stronger returns than traditional investing, as well as a host of findings that question its comparative benefit, Taylor said.

“There have been thousands of studies,” she said. “The jury is out on whether ESG delivers higher returns.”

Why have some Republican officials criticized ESG investing?

Republican politicians have criticized ESG because they say they consider it an effort to use financial tools for the purpose of advancing liberal political goals.

In some cases, Republicans have condemned the investing approach as a departure from free market capitalism, since it takes into account non-financial factors.

In a Wall Street Journal op-ed last year, former Vice President Mike Pence said, “The woke left is poised to conquer corporate America and has set in motion a strategy to enforce their radical environmental and social agenda on publicly traded corporations.”

“For the free market to thrive, it must be truly free,” he added.

In response to such attacks, proponents of ESG reject the notion that they’re deviating from investment fundamentals, since looming threats like climate change will have a profound impact on how the economy operates, Taylor said.

“Whether you’re on the left or right, you’re currently making the argument that you’re the rational capitalist and your opponent is the partisan hack,” she said.

Criticism leveled at ESG has not only come from the right, however. Progressives have criticized the practice for imposing vague or weak standards on companies, offering the imprimatur of virtue without the requirement of substantive action.

“Everybody hates ESG,” Taylor said. “The left hates ESG because they say we should not just think about issues when they have an impact on a company’s bottom line. There’s an imperative to address racism and climate change.

In response to criticism of ESG, BlackRock told ABC News in a statement: “Over the past year, BlackRock has been subject to campaigns suggesting we are either ‘too progressive’ or ‘too conservative’ in how we manage our clients’ money. We are neither. We are a fiduciary.”

“We put our clients’ interests first and deliver the investment choices and performance they need. We will not let these campaigns sway us from delivering for our clients,” the statement added.

What have Republican officials done to oppose ESG?

So far, attacks on ESG have primarily arisen at the state level, where some Republican-led states have divested their pension funds from firms that engage in ESG investing, while others have put forward legislation that would ban any public entity from carrying out financial business with such firms, including routine local policy decisions like raising money through selling bonds.

In August, 19 state attorneys general sent a letter to Fink criticizing the firm’s use of ESG criteria in overseeing state pension funds. That month, DeSantis approved a resolution that eliminates the consideration of ESG from decisions used in managing Florida’s pension investments.

On Monday, DeSantis took the effort further, proposing a set of measures that prohibit the consideration of ESG criteria by financial institutions in Florida, as well as banning the use of such criteria in all investments made at the state and local level, among other provisions.

“By applying arbitrary ESG financial metrics that serve no one except the companies that created them, elites are circumventing the ballot box to implement a radical ideological agenda,” DeSantis said in a statement on Monday.

Republican states face financial consequences for such measures, Henisz said, noting the higher fees charged by smaller financial institutions that forego ESG investing. Texas cities will pay between $303 million and $532 million in additional interest on $32 billion in bonds due to the state’s ESG ban, a Wharton School of Business study found in July.

“The cost to the taxpayers in these states will limit how far they go,” Henisz said. “It’s more rhetoric than reality in terms of how divided the financial services sector gets.”

Copyright © 2023, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.

Scottish leader Nicola Sturgeon, supporter of independence and opponent of Brexit, to resign

Scottish leader Nicola Sturgeon, supporter of independence and opponent of Brexit, to resign
Scottish leader Nicola Sturgeon, supporter of independence and opponent of Brexit, to resign
Jane Barlow/POOL/AFP via Getty Images

(LONDON) — Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, a supporter of independence for Scotland, said on Wednesday she plans to resign.

She cited her duty to step back amid the “nature and scale” of the challenges facing her country. Sturgeon, who has served for more than eight years, said new leadership would have “the energy” needed to lead the government and to push for Scotland to break away from the United Kingdom.

“I am firmly of the view that there is now majority support for independence,” she said in a statement. “But that support needs to be solidified — and it needs to grow further if our independent Scotland is to have the best possible foundation.”

She added, “To achieve that we need to reach across the divide in Scottish politics, and my judgement now is that this needs a new leader.”

Sturgeon said she plans to continue in the role until a successor is ready to take office.

British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak in a statement thanked Sturgeon for her long-standing service.

“I wish her all the best for her next steps,” Sunak said on Twitter. “We will continue to work closely with the @scotgov on our joint efforts to deliver for people across Scotland.”

Copyright © 2023, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.

Tesla to open some of its charging stations, as Biden seeks to expand US network

Tesla to open some of its charging stations, as Biden seeks to expand US network
Tesla to open some of its charging stations, as Biden seeks to expand US network
contrastaddict/Getty Images

(NEW YORK) — Tesla plans to open a portion of its U.S. charging network to competing electric vehicle makers, the Biden administration said on Wednesday.

The carmaker plans to open about 7,500 charging stations across the U.S. before the end of 2024, officials said on Wednesday.

The update from Elon Musk’s car company comes as the White House rolls out new measures to expand EV charging across the country.

The Biden administration announced it had partnered with Tesla and other companies — including General Motors and Hertz — as part of a two-year project that aims to use “private funds to complement federal dollars and putting the nation’s EV charging goals even closer within reach.”

Tesla plans to install about 3,500 new stations on highways across the country, the White House said. Those new charges are expected to be open to other vehicles.

“All EV drivers will be able to access these stations using the Tesla app or website,” the White House said. “Additionally, Tesla will triple its full nationwide network of Superchargers, manufactured in Buffalo, New York.”

Copyright © 2023, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.

Lawsuit accuses Cedars-Sinai hospital’s website of sharing patient data with Meta, Google

Lawsuit accuses Cedars-Sinai hospital’s website of sharing patient data with Meta, Google
Lawsuit accuses Cedars-Sinai hospital’s website of sharing patient data with Meta, Google
Thir Sakdi Phu Cxm / EyeEm/Getty Images

(LOS ANGELES) — A lawsuit against Cedars-Sinai Health System and Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles claims the hospital shared patient data with third parties.

Filed by plaintiff John Doe, the proposed class action lawsuit claims his and other patients’ private information — including data related to their medical inquiries — was shared with marketing and social media platforms including Google, Microsoft Bing and Meta, the parent company of Facebook.

“Cedars-Sinai transmitted to third parties portions of the patients’ private communications with it through pieces of tracking code that it embedded in its website, for the sole purpose of sharing such information with marketing entities,” the lawsuit reads. “This code served as real time wiretaps on patients’ communications.”

According to the lawsuit, originally reported by The Register, patients at Cedars-Sinai can use either the hospital’s website or its app to log into the patient portal and research symptoms about their medical conditions, about doctors who can treat said conditions, as well as other issues related to their health.

However, the lawsuit claims Cedars-Sinai’s website had Meta Pixel programmed. Meta Pixel is a piece of code that can help identify how Facebook users are interacting with content on a website.

Allegedly, when a patient entered any of the following information — types of medical treatment sought; name, sex, language and specialty of a physician; searches related to COVID-19 information and treatment; locations where treatment was sought; or that a telephone call was made to schedule an appointment — it was shared simultaneously with Meta.

“By way of illustration, if a patient made an appointment with a doctor for treatment of cancer, the tracking code Cedars-Sinai put on its website conveyed that information to Meta, which in turn allowed Meta to include that patient in marketing target groups that it offered to its other advertising clients who wanted to market to cancer patients,” according to the lawsuit.

The lawsuit claims John Doe “has noticed an increase in the number of health-related ads that he has received, and he has received ads relating to the condition about which he communicated on Defendant’s website.”

The lawsuit argues this is in violation of Cedars-Sinai’s privacy policy, which assures user information is protected and won’t be shared for other services unless specifically requested by the patient.

In a statement to ABC News, a Cedars-Sinai spokesman said the hospital upholds patient privacy but did not comment on the allegations.

“We are unable [to] comment on pending litigation, but we can say that the health and medical privacy of our patients and community are of the utmost importance,” the statement said. “We will continue to follow regulatory guidance in this area while striving to provide the best website experience for people searching for healthcare information and treatment options.”

Meta declined to comment on the lawsuit but pointed ABC News to their Business Tools policies that prohibit advertisers from sharing an individual’s sensitive health information.

“We have no statement at this time beyond the allegations plead in the complaint,” Rachele Byrd, managing partner of firm Wolf Haldenstein Adler Freeman & Herz’s San Diego office and one of the attorneys for the plaintiff, told ABC News in an email.

Meta is not the only defendant in the lawsuit. The lawsuit also claims Cedars-Sinai placed tracking codes from Google Analytics and Microsoft Bing on its website to help target website visitors with more personal advertisements.

“Google Analytics is a measurement product that helps businesses better understand their web and app performance — businesses own the data collected and can delete it at any time,” a Google spokesperson said in a statement to ABC News. “As a product, Google Analytics was built so that users could not be identified by Google for ourselves or anyone else and data in Google Analytics is obfuscated and aggregated. Additionally, we have strict policies against advertising to people based on sensitive information and take action when a customer violates these terms.”

Microsoft did not immediately respond to ABC News’ request for comment.

This is not the first time Meta has been targeted in a lawsuit for use of its Meta Pixel.

In a proposed class action lawsuit filed in Louisiana last month, patients alleged LCMC Health Systems, based in New Orleans, and Willis-Knighton Health System, based in northwestern Louisiana, shared sensitive medical data without patients’ knowledge or consent.

“We are learning more and more about this shocking breach of trust as our investigation continues,” attorney Stephen Herman, a partner at law firm Herman Herman & Katz, which is representing the plaintiffs in the Louisiana case, told ABC News in a statement. “This was a gross invasion of privacy that went on for years.”

Copyright © 2023, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.

Queen Camilla to wear controversial Queen Mary’s Crown at coronation

Queen Camilla to wear controversial Queen Mary’s Crown at coronation
Queen Camilla to wear controversial Queen Mary’s Crown at coronation
ALASTAIR GRANT/POOL/AFP via Getty Images

(LONDON) — The exact crown Camilla, the queen consort, will wear at the coronation in May has finally been announced.

Camilla, who will be crowned alongside her husband King Charles III, will wear the Queen Mary’s Crown, Buckingham Palace confirmed Tuesday.

The crown has been removed from the display at the Tower of London in order to make modifications to it ahead of the May 6, 2023, coronation, the palace said.

Camilla’s decision to wear the Queen Mary’s Crown at the coronation brings with it some controversy and a historic first.

This will be the first time in “recent history” that a queen consort has used an existing crown for a coronation, instead of having a new one made, according to the palace.

The palace described Camilla’s decision to re-wear the Queen Mary’s Crown as one made “in the interests of sustainability and efficiency.”

The Queen Mary’s Crown has a complicated history due to the types of diamonds it originally contained.

The crown was created for the 1911 coronation of King George V, according to the Royal Collection Trust. Set with 2,200 diamonds, the crown was worn by his wife Queen Mary at the coronation.

When it was first made, the crown contained three large diamonds, the Kohinoor and Cullinan III and IV diamonds, according to the Royal Collection Trust.

Buckingham Palace said this week that for the coronation in May, the crown will be reset with the Cullinan III, IV and V diamonds, each of which were also worn by the late Queen Elizabeth II.

“The diamonds were part of Queen Elizabeth II’s personal jewellery collection for many years and were often worn by Her late Majesty as brooches,” the palace said in a statement.

The queen’s death last September reignited calls for some of the diamonds in the crown jewels to be returned to their countries of origin.

The Kohinoor diamond was mined in India thousands of years ago and is one of the largest cut diamonds in the world.

Over the centuries, India, Pakistan, Iran and Afghanistan have all claimed ownership and called for the British to surrender it, but the British government has rejected pleas to return the Kohinoor diamond.

Historic Royal Palaces, which oversees the Tower of London, notes that the diamond has a “turbulent history” and is a “symbol of conquest.”

The Cullinan diamond was discovered in South Africa in 1905 in a mine owned by its namesake, Thomas Cullinan.

It was later purchased by the government in the former province of Transvaal, South Africa — which was dissolved in 1994 after the fall of apartheid — where it was found, and “presented to the reigning British monarch, King Edward VII,” according to Encyclopedia Britannica.

The Royal Collection Trust states that the diamond was presented to the king “as a symbolic gesture to heal the rift between Britain and South Africa after the Boer War.”

Copyright © 2023, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.

Nearly 70,000 people have reported ‘romance scam,’ with losses topping $1.3B last year: FTC

Nearly 70,000 people have reported ‘romance scam,’ with losses topping .3B last year: FTC
Nearly 70,000 people have reported ‘romance scam,’ with losses topping .3B last year: FTC
Karl Tapales/Getty Images

(NEW YORK) — Romance scammers raked in big bucks in 2022, deceiving almost 70,000 people out of $1.3 billion, according to a new report from the Federal Trade Commission.

According to the FBI, romance scammers create an online identity to gain a person’s trust and affection and then use that relationship to steal or manipulate them.

Last year, romance scammers stole from tens of thousands of victims with a median reported loss of $4,400 each, the FTC said.

Romance scammers use dating apps to target people, but are more likely to send people a private message to establish a relationship, according to the FTC.

Approximately 40% of people who lost money in 2022 said scammers contacted them on social media, while 19% said it began on an app or a website, according to the FTC. The FTC noted that popular messaging apps such as Google Chat, Telegram and WhatsApp were used to continue conversations.

According to the FTC report, romance scammers often use specific lies to scam people.

Approximately 24% of romance scammers tell potential victims that they or a loved one is “sick, hurt, or in jail;” 18% offer to teach how to invest; another 18% say they’re in the military; and 12% use lies surrounding getting married, according to the FTC.

The FTC said that last year 24% of people reported paying scammers using gift cards, 19% paid in cryptocurrency, and 14% paid using a bank wire transfer or payment.

Over 60% of reported losses stemmed from bank wire transfers and cryptocurrency payments, the latter making up the largest reported dollar amount in 2022, according to the FTC.

Last month, a Florida woman was arrested for planning a years-long romance scam that defrauded an 87-year-old Holocaust survivor.

According to federal prosecutors, Peaches Stergo stole $2.8 million over four years from the victim, whom she met on a dating website.

“Stergo deceived an 87-year-old Holocaust survivor, maliciously draining his life savings so she could become a millionaire through fraud,” U.S. Attorney Damian Williams said in a statement.

The FTC does provide ways to spot a romance scammer in action:

  • Nobody legit will ever ask you to help — or insist that you invest — by sending cryptocurrency, giving the numbers on a gift card, or wiring money. Anyone who does is a scammer.
  •  If someone tells you to send money to receive a package, you can bet it’s a scam.
  • Talk to friends or family about a new love interest and pay attention if they’re concerned.
  • Try a reverse image search of profile pictures. If the details don’t match up, it’s a scam.

Copyright © 2023, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.